A beachside house with a for rent sign, a concerned local talking to a traveler holding a suitcase, near tropical plants and calm ocean.
Vacation Rental Scams Locals Warn Are Growing Faster Than Ever
Written by Isabella Bird on 5/18/2025

High-Pressure Sales Tactics

This one’s wild. If a host’s replies start sounding like a late-night infomercial—“Book now or lose your spot! Only two hours left!”—I want to throw my laptop. Locals say scammers love urgent texts, demanding deposits through wire transfer, Venmo, or some weird app nobody’s heard of.

Two friends got identical DMs full of emojis and fake countdowns. Legit hosts never rush you off-platform or make you pay in minutes. Every rental agent I trust says: if they threaten to cancel unless you act now, run. Classic scam move.

My neighbor’s “host” offered her a fake “off-platform savings” if she canceled her real booking and wired money. Lost the deposit, and the property was halfway across the country from where it was supposed to be. If anyone asks for payment by gift card or outside the platform? Block, delete, warn everyone.

Fake Listings and Identity Theft

Fake listings are everywhere now, and they’re getting weirder every week. Renting a place shouldn’t mean risking your credit score, but after hearing about Canadian renters losing $3.4 million to bogus rent-to-own deals (True Canadian Finds), I’m about ready to just camp in my car next trip. Anyone who thinks a “verified” ad is safe probably hasn’t doomscrolled through enough sketchy listings at 2 a.m.

Spotting Fake Listings

Ever stared at a rental listing and thought, “$1200 for a downtown loft—no pets, no questions, no way this is legit”? Yeah, same. The warning signs smack you in the face if you’re even half awake. I’ve scrolled past enough weirdly cheap places with stock-photo-perfect kitchens and landlords who email from addresses that look like random Wi-Fi passwords. One time, some “agent” sent me a grainy PDF and demanded a wire transfer—like, sure, let me just Venmo a stranger because you said so. HuffPost even points out how scammers practically beg you to pay off-platform. I’ve called numbers from ads and always get this “Oh, I’m out of the country” routine, or they’re “in meetings for days”—but hey, just send your deposit and trust you’ll get a key, right? Honestly, I’ve ignored my own better judgment more than once, just because the place looked amazing and I wanted to believe. Probably some kid halfway around the world laughing at me.

Reverse Image Search for Rental Photos

If the apartment looks like a magazine spread—seriously, who lives like that?—I dump those pics straight into Google’s reverse image search or TinEye. Half the time, boom, the same living room is for rent in Barcelona and also, weirdly, in Calgary. Saw the same balcony, identical throw pillows, listed in Vancouver and Miami. Not even subtle. If you’re lazy like me, grab that “search by image” Chrome plugin and save yourself from emailing scammers. Met this guy who thought he found his dream pad, only to realize the photos were lifted from a Parisian Airbnb. It’s equal parts hilarious and infuriating when you catch them, and honestly, I still can’t believe I almost wired rent for a living room that probably doesn’t exist on this planet.

Risks of Identity Theft

Losing money sucks, but honestly, losing your identity is nightmare fuel. After reading Vanmates on scammers hoarding passport scans and pay stubs “for paperwork,” I nearly quit applying online. My friend handed over her ID once, and next thing she knows, her credit got checked for loans she never even heard of. The Better Business Bureau said rental scams were Canada’s third riskiest scam in 2023, but nobody’s out here warning about the data theft—everyone’s too busy drooling over quartz countertops. Now I redact everything, slap “FOR RENTAL APPLICATION ONLY” in giant letters, and still, I find myself grilling landlords about where they store my info (as if a scammer cares). Why do we hand over everything just for a maybe-chance at a July 1 move-in? Wild.

Payment Methods and Financial Risks

Renting online? Blink and your money’s gone. I hear people grumble about scams all the time, and honestly, it’s not paranoia—payment apps, ancient wire transfers, and the classic “where’s my deposit?” spiral. That’s the rental scene.

Safe vs. Risky Payment Methods

Venmo, Cash App, PayPal Friends and Family—yeah, no. Every time I mention sending rent with those, bank tellers look like I just confessed to a crime. Airbnb’s payment system is the only thing I halfway trust, but anywhere else? I’ve watched people lose thousands in the time it takes to microwave leftovers.

My landlord buddy won’t even touch checks now. If a listing wants me to pay “off-platform,” I get the same feeling as when I walk past a dark alley at midnight. Mailing cash? I mean, technically it’s an option, but who’s ever seen that money again if things go sideways? No one I know.

The Dangers of Wire Transfers

Wiring money is like launching it into space—there’s no coming back. FBI numbers—11,500+ cases and $350 million gone in 2021—pop up every time someone says, “Just wire the deposit.” Why do scammers love wires so much?

I’ve never had a legit rental company ask for a wire. It’s always someone’s “cousin” with a “special deal.” My neighbor almost did it: “Send now or lose the place.” Then, poof—blocked, vanished, money gone. At least with a credit card, you can fight for a chargeback. With cash, just toss it in the river.

Protecting Your Security Deposit

Security deposits are their own brand of anxiety. I hand over money hoping for a key, and then get stuck on hold with “customer service” for eternity. I only use sites that keep deposits in escrow or secure channels. If someone asks for prepaid debit cards or gift cards, I’m out. I’ve heard too many stories over coffee about people losing deposits to sketchy landlords.

Half the horror stories start with “I didn’t use a reputable platform.” One guy paid a “processing fee”—lost two grand, never saw the apartment. Now I only book places with clear terms and insurance guarantees (Airbnb’s AirCover, Vrbo’s Book with Confidence). I’d rather have my deposit in limbo than in some scammer’s crypto wallet.